My Profile | Active Users | Help | Search | Google Search


  
George@Fourtitude
Fourtitude Staff

Offline

Member Since
4-9-2004
13121 posts

Hershey PA
2010 S4 (on order), 1984 4000 quattro x 2 , PREVIOUS CARS - 1991 200 Turbo quattro, 2002 A4 Avant 1

 Driven: 2007 Audi S3« »

At the tender age of 10, I made a solemn promise to myself that my first car would be an Audi ur-quattro, just like the one I watched rally ace Hannu Mikkola slip-sliding through forests and fields of ice on TV in the early ‘80s. The offbeat warble of the five-cylinder engine, those flared arches and angular proportions: I was hooked.

Full Story



-G
10 S4 | 84 4000 S quattro
FOURTITUDE on TWITTER
FOURTITUDE on FACEBOOK
FOURTITUDE on MYSPACE

angryrican66
Member



Offline

Member Since
4-16-2006
3323 posts

Harrison NY
2007 A3 3.2Q Open Sky,Bose,Technology,Cold Weather, Nav,Roof Rails Ibis White

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

Quote, originally posted by George@Fourtitude »

At the tender age of 10, I made a solemn promise to myself that my first car would be an Audi ur-quattro, just like the one I watched rally ace Hannu Mikkola slip-sliding through forests and fields of ice on TV in the early ‘80s. The offbeat warble of the five-cylinder engine, those flared arches and angular proportions: I was hooked.

Full Story

I really want one, in Mango Orange



/Euro S-Line Spings&Shocks/Haldex GenII/

http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...8.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...s.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...9.jpg

Xerxes
Member

Offline

Member Since
9-20-2006
1930 posts

Los Alamos NM
DeathStar

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (angryrican66) »« »

It's a nice car, but I fail to see the value proposition compared to, say, a Mazdaspeed 3 or even a Volvo C30. The ratio of go to show and go to money is too low.



Hans Struck » BMW, I'm bending over for you with my pants around my ankles -- give it to me!!!

GLS_VR6 » I guess the E90 turned out to be a dissapointment to be, largely because I could see how better the E46 was

vwgilly » -Texas is not the South.

navybean
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-3-2002
1357 posts

Irvine CA
2008 VW Passat, 2009 Honda Odessey

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (Xerxes) »« »

i would love to have a five door s3!



Naveen

God Bless America and George W.

wish list:
Audi S4 Avant, RS4, BMW M3 sedan, Ford Mustang Shelby GT500KR, Dodge Challenger

PDXA4
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-9-2001
492 posts

Santa Clara CA
03, D2 S8

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

We should start a petition to Audi to bring the S3 to America...Just like what was done for the R32 with VW...

Audi would sell every S3 that it could import without issue here...

I'd be happy to take one as a 5-door if this was the easier route for Audi to import it...

What I want is the 2.0T + Quattro + Manual ...Please Please Please...



Current: 03 D2 S8, Ming Blue
Current: 08 GTi, 4-door, DSG, Sunroof, iPod, United Gray
Current: 06 Mazda MX-5, multiple mods
Former: 03 B6 A4 Avant 1.8TQFormer: 04 Passat 1.9L TDi EurospecFormer: 00 B5 A4 1.8T, multiple multiple mods
3dr A3 3.2
Member



Offline

Member Since
12-28-2004
2957 posts

france
2005 3dr Audi A3 3.2 Q - Manual

  »« »

George, great article once again!

But 17" brakes? Don't think so.
Aluminum bearings? Nope, but there are aluminum bearing carriers (spindles).

It's nice to see we have Quattro GmbH developed goodies we can fit to our cars, and the faster steering rack looks to be one of those gems.

The lap-timer-enabled NAVI+ software would be very nice as well!



Ben's home-grown RS3:
3dr Audi A3 3.2 Quattro MT6 - KW V3 - HPP - H&R - Stasis 14.5" front BBK - VF mounts - DG - Nspd RS-6
OSIR design fenders / S3 body kit.
HPA\\\ FT450, Peloquin TBD , Spec SM FW and clutch, EvoMS intake & Snow Boost Cooler. Phil @ BSH =
StoicDude
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-16-2002
2607 posts

Reno NV
Golf 5 R32

 Re: (3dr A3 3.2) »« »

Nice article. Too bad Audi of America is not going to bring the car over.
mookieblaylock
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-25-2005
1264 posts

planet mergatron ca
ktm 690 e

  »« »

nice article. Somehow i'm not sure this is the one 10 year olds dream about. That would be the original sport quatro. It's cool though that audi has made a raw and focussed car after so many overweight luxobarges (except rs4) Send my s3 with i5 t engine w/350 horse in that nasy orange colour
George@Fourtitude
Fourtitude Staff

Offline

Member Since
4-9-2004
13121 posts

Hershey PA
2010 S4 (on order), 1984 4000 quattro x 2 , PREVIOUS CARS - 1991 200 Turbo quattro, 2002 A4 Avant 1

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (Xerxes) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Xerxes »
It's a nice car, but I fail to see the value proposition compared to, say, a Mazdaspeed 3 or even a Volvo C30. The ratio of go to show and go to money is too low.

Volvo C30 may be closer in comparison, but isn't as fast or as quality on the inside where Audi really shines. Those who want performance over anything else will go with the Mazda, the Lancer or the Subaru. However, I still think there's a business case for it, as there is with the A3 over the Mazda3 5-door.



-G
10 S4 | 84 4000 S quattro
FOURTITUDE on TWITTER
FOURTITUDE on FACEBOOK
FOURTITUDE on MYSPACE

George@Fourtitude
Fourtitude Staff

Offline

Member Since
4-9-2004
13121 posts

Hershey PA
2010 S4 (on order), 1984 4000 quattro x 2 , PREVIOUS CARS - 1991 200 Turbo quattro, 2002 A4 Avant 1

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (PDXA4) »« »

Quote, originally posted by PDXA4 »
We should start a petition to Audi to bring the S3 to America...Just like what was done for the R32 with VW...

Audi would sell every S3 that it could import without issue here...

I'd be happy to take one as a 5-door if this was the easier route for Audi to import it...

What I want is the 2.0T + Quattro + Manual ...Please Please Please...

Quote, originally posted by PDXA4 »
We should start a petition to Audi to bring the S3 to America...Just like what was done for the R32 with VW...

Audi would sell every S3 that it could import without issue here...

I'd be happy to take one as a 5-door if this was the easier route for Audi to import it...

What I want is the 2.0T + Quattro + Manual ...Please Please Please...

If you guys wanted to do a petition, I'll pass it along to product planning.

BTW, don't count on the optional Recaros (same as RS 4) because they would fail for US market for same passenger airbag sensor reason.



-G
10 S4 | 84 4000 S quattro
FOURTITUDE on TWITTER
FOURTITUDE on FACEBOOK
FOURTITUDE on MYSPACE

George@Fourtitude
Fourtitude Staff

Offline

Member Since
4-9-2004
13121 posts

Hershey PA
2010 S4 (on order), 1984 4000 quattro x 2 , PREVIOUS CARS - 1991 200 Turbo quattro, 2002 A4 Avant 1

 Re: (3dr A3 3.2) »« »

Quote, originally posted by 3dr A3 3.2 »
George, great article once again!

But 17" brakes? Don't think so.
Aluminum bearings? Nope, but there are aluminum bearing carriers (spindles).

It's nice to see we have Quattro GmbH developed goodies we can fit to our cars, and the faster steering rack looks to be one of those gems.

The lap-timer-enabled NAVI+ software would be very nice as well!

The article was written by a UK contributor. They report brake sizes differently over there, as in the minimum wheel diameter that will clear the rotors. That's the discrepancy in size, though I failed to catch them on my edit last evening.



-G
10 S4 | 84 4000 S quattro
FOURTITUDE on TWITTER
FOURTITUDE on FACEBOOK
FOURTITUDE on MYSPACE

Travis Grundke
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-26-1999
1422 posts

Cleveland Ohio
2006 Audi A3 Sport 6MT, Nav+/Sound, Open Sky, Xenon, Convenience, Cold Weather

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

I'm going to be the contrarian to those clamoring for an S3 here in North America. Looking at what Audi NA would most likely have to charge for this beast (~$40k), I find it quite difficult to make a business justification. The S3 is no-doubt brilliant, but we're talking über large bucks for an already relatively limited market segment in North America.

I would tend to think that the number of potential buyers in the $40k segment would prefer an S4, 3 series coupe or the like in lieu of the S3. The R32 will fill in the $30k segment very well, but even there Volkswagen took nearly 18 months to sell through the 5000 (?) 2004 models. Audi is having a hard time selling 8,000 A3s annually in the US, I find it difficult to believe that the cost entailed to certify the S3 for NA sale would be recouped easily.



Travis L. Grundke
tgrundke@gmail.com
2006 Audi A3 Sport, Cold Weather, Xenon, Open Sky, Nav+, Sound
PDXA4
Member



Offline

Member Since
10-9-2001
492 posts

Santa Clara CA
03, D2 S8

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

Quote, originally posted by George@Fourtitude »

If you guys wanted to do a petition, I'll pass it along to product planning.

BTW, don't count on the optional Recaros (same as RS 4) because they would fail for US market for same passenger airbag sensor reason.

Sounds good to me George...

The seats don't interest me....What the majority of us want is the Quattro drivetrain with the 2.0T and Manual transmission...



Current: 03 D2 S8, Ming Blue
Current: 08 GTi, 4-door, DSG, Sunroof, iPod, United Gray
Current: 06 Mazda MX-5, multiple mods
Former: 03 B6 A4 Avant 1.8TQFormer: 04 Passat 1.9L TDi EurospecFormer: 00 B5 A4 1.8T, multiple multiple mods
EuroA3_7
Member



Offline

Member Since
11-14-2006
5 posts

Edina MN
2006 Audi A3 2.0T 6MT Sport Red, Convinience, Cold Weather, Xenon

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (PDXA4) »« »

Couldn't agree more.
All I really want to see is an A3 with 2.0T + quattro + manual tran.

Travis' post does make sense. Audi would have to charge about 40k. A3, as is already pushing into the A4 territory.

Don't get me wrong I've been such a huge fan of the A3 for the last 10 years and absolutely love my A3 2.0T. But I could justify buying the used A3 because it was cheaper without the quattro. Other wise add the quattro add the s-line - well why shouldn't I buy the A4 then.

Of course S3 would be great but Audi would screw up the pricing…
Instead of buying the S3 I would trade in my 2.0T for a manual Quattro 2.0T and chip it right away.


angryrican66
Member



Offline

Member Since
4-16-2006
3323 posts

Harrison NY
2007 A3 3.2Q Open Sky,Bose,Technology,Cold Weather, Nav,Roof Rails Ibis White

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (EuroA3_7) »« »

Quote, originally posted by EuroA3_7 »
Couldn't agree more.
All I really want to see is an A3 with 2.0T + quattro + manual tran.

Travis' post does make sense. Audi would have to charge about 40k. A3, as is already pushing into the A4 territory.

Don't get me wrong I've been such a huge fan of the A3 for the last 10 years and absolutely love my A3 2.0T. But I could justify buying the used A3 because it was cheaper without the quattro. Other wise add the quattro add the s-line - well why shouldn't I buy the A4 then.

Of course S3 would be great but Audi would screw up the pricing…
Instead of buying the S3 I would trade in my 2.0T for a manual Quattro 2.0T and chip it right away.

Seems like Audi should revisit their current configuration,
though I doubt most would actually buy an S3 sportback, the 2.0T
with quattro is so far the most requested non existing platform in the US

see the link, I did this last night

http://forums.vwvortex.com/zerothread?id=2971355



/Euro S-Line Spings&Shocks/Haldex GenII/

http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...8.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...s.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...9.jpg

Travis Grundke
Member



Offline

Member Since
5-26-1999
1422 posts

Cleveland Ohio
2006 Audi A3 Sport 6MT, Nav+/Sound, Open Sky, Xenon, Convenience, Cold Weather

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (angryrican66) »« »

Precisely. Were Audi to put resources toward something, they would no doubt get a significantly higher return on investment to release the A3 2.0T Quattro in North America instead of trying to push a very expensive, limited market S3.

The packaging on the A3 needs to be reconfigured to make it a better value in North America. Audi is under extremely heavy currency-valuation related pressures when it comes to pricing. As is, I'm sticking to my recommendation that Audi improve the value of the A3 by bumping the base price to $26.5/27k, but with that, include Quattro, Xenons, Convenience package and a standard sunroof.

Options shoudl be pared down: sport vs. premium, Opensky, Navigation+Bose

This offers greater overall value to the vehicle. As it is, people look at the A3 and think, "for a few thousand more, I can get an A4!", especially if you load up on options. However, were Audi to package the A3 such that you get a heckuvalot for your dollar, the two cars become very distinct models.

For those who have spent a lot of time in the A4 and the A3, I think you find that after the initial impressions wear off, the A4 feels to be a more substantial car than the A3. That alone accounts for a great deal of difference (besides the whole hatchback thing, ya know.)

Quote, originally posted by angryrican66 »
Seems like Audi should revisit their current configuration,
though I doubt most would actually buy an S3 sportback, the 2.0T
with quattro is so far the most requested non existing platform in the US

see the link, I did this last night

http://forums.vwvortex.com/zerothread?id=2971355





Travis L. Grundke
tgrundke@gmail.com
2006 Audi A3 Sport, Cold Weather, Xenon, Open Sky, Nav+, Sound
StoicDude
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-16-2002
2607 posts

Reno NV
Golf 5 R32

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (Travis Grundke) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Travis Grundke »

This offers greater overall value to the vehicle. As it is, people look at the A3 and think, "for a few thousand more, I can get an A4!", especially if you load up on options. However, were Audi to package the A3 such that you get a heckuvalot for your dollar, the two cars become very distinct models.

Exactly my thinking, or even consider the Passat Wagon.

S3 is a different thing.

2.0+quattro= winner
TDI + quattro= winner for life.

1552
Member.

Offline

Member Since
2-2-2000
4766 posts

Sarasota, Florida

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (Travis Grundke) »« »

Quote, originally posted by Travis Grundke »
I'm going to be the contrarian to those clamoring for an S3 here in North America. Looking at what Audi NA would most likely have to charge for this beast (~$40k), I find it quite difficult to make a business justification. The S3 is no-doubt brilliant, but we're talking über large bucks for an already relatively limited market segment in North America.

I tend to agree. IMO, the S3 would appeal mostly to existing Audi fans but have little potential for conquest sales as the competition (at the predicted price point) is rather fierce. Given that, I can understand Audi's reluctance to bring the S3 here.

angryrican66
Member



Offline

Member Since
4-16-2006
3323 posts

Harrison NY
2007 A3 3.2Q Open Sky,Bose,Technology,Cold Weather, Nav,Roof Rails Ibis White

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (1552) »« »

well just to clear and bring pricing to reallity here , heck apples to apples comrads I went on the Audi car builder and designed two almost identically equipped A3 and A4, huge diffenrence in price ,since I keep hearing for that price I should get an A4, yeah a barebones A4,

A3
Sportback S-Line 2.0T FWD 6MT
Cold Weather
Rear Airbags
Bose Audio
Technology with Bluetooth
Open Sky
$32450+1800 if Quattro were availabe
with 2.0T
$34250

A4
Avant Quattro 2.0T S-line 6MT
Cold Weather
Rear Air Bags
Bose Audio
Convenience+Blue Tooth
Sunroof(included in S-line Pkg)
$39915.00

that is a whopping $4800 difference, in case anyone is wondering
an S4 with the same package is a whopping $51575!!!!
What is my point? The S3 is a speciality low sales volume car
$42-46 isn't really that bad, for a car only a few people would buy Just in case I used $1800 as an average figure for
the difference between same engine same option Fwd to Quattro Audi's


Modified by angryrican66 at 5:40 PM 12-11-2006

Modified by angryrican66 at 7:04 PM 12-11-2006



/Euro S-Line Spings&Shocks/Haldex GenII/

http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...8.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...s.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...9.jpg

StoicDude
Member

Offline

Member Since
4-16-2002
2607 posts

Reno NV
Golf 5 R32

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (angryrican66) »« »

The main people that cross shop the A3 and the A4 ar ethe ones that are looking at the 3.2 Quattro A3, vs the 2.0T Avant. That is my case at least.

People usually cross shop the GTI against the A3 2.0T


angryrican66
Member



Offline

Member Since
4-16-2006
3323 posts

Harrison NY
2007 A3 3.2Q Open Sky,Bose,Technology,Cold Weather, Nav,Roof Rails Ibis White

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (StoicDude) »« »

Quote, originally posted by StoicDude »
The main people that cross shop the A3 and the A4 ar ethe ones that are looking at the 3.2 Quattro A3, vs the 2.0T Avant. That is my case at least.

People usually cross shop the GTI against the A3 2.0T

Thats not an apples to apples comparison, A3 2.0 =MKV GTI
apples to apples , A4 2.0T = Passat 2.0T apples to apples, A3 3.2T V6
Quattro> A4 Avant 2.0T Quattro not apples to apples,



/Euro S-Line Spings&Shocks/Haldex GenII/

http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...8.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...s.jpg
http://i98.photobucket.com/alb...9.jpg

SB_07A3
Member

Offline

Member Since
8-28-2006
267 posts

Torrance CA

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (angryrican66) »« »

Does anyone know if that shift knob with the s3 logo on it is available to be purchased?



| 2007 Audi A3 | 6MT | S-line | Sprint Blue | Open Sky | Bose | Sirius | Bluetooth |
| Blindside Mirrors | Aluminum Pedals | S4 Aluminum Mirror Covers | AWE Boost Gauge | Euro S-Line Springs |
| JSP Short Shifter | Pendulum and Dogbone Mount |
| APR - 91&Stock | Carbonio Intake | Neuspeed Hi-Flow Discharge and Intercooler Pipe |


George@Fourtitude
Fourtitude Staff

Offline

Member Since
4-9-2004
13121 posts

Hershey PA
2010 S4 (on order), 1984 4000 quattro x 2 , PREVIOUS CARS - 1991 200 Turbo quattro, 2002 A4 Avant 1

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (SB_07A3) »« »

Once the S3 is fully on the market, I don't know why a European parts source couldn't source it.



-G
10 S4 | 84 4000 S quattro
FOURTITUDE on TWITTER
FOURTITUDE on FACEBOOK
FOURTITUDE on MYSPACE

bacchus2678
Member

Offline

Member Since
7-23-2005
23 posts

Daniel Island SC

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

In no way would this ever be worth the money for the performance you get.
feels_road
Member



Offline

Member Since
1-27-2005
10803 posts

Bay Area, CA
2000 GLX 4Motion Passat Wagon & 1993 Golf

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (Travis Grundke) »« »

Well, recently a number of cars VW/Audi have offered are approximately sold for the same $ number as the Euro number. They may no longer be able to do that, given current exchange rates, but on paper this would mean an S3 for not much more than the R32. In Germany, R32: Euro 32,500, S3: Euro 35,000. Supposedly the R32 will be priced at just under $33,000, in the US.

Given that the bad exchange rate either means losses or pricing the car out of its market spot, I too see a much better business case for a regular 2.0TFSI quattro A3. (hey I just happen to be a fan of that combination, anyway). It's an Audi, so just put in heated leather, Xenons and a sunroof standard, and keep other options simple and few. Despite the 5 doors it will still cost federalization $$ if the rumors about the tank & manual combo are true, but if they can sell 5000 of these vs. perhaps 1500 of the S3, that should compensate. IMO, to keep cost down, they should put in a less expensive (than the S3), only slightly beefed up 230-240hp version of the engine that has the smaller turbo with virtually no lag, which is what Americans may prefer to drive, anyway. Also only use steering and suspension upgrades of the S3 that are cost-effective. Keep the entry price close to the regular A3, +$1500 to 2000 for the Haldex.

As to apples and oranges, I think size-wise, the A4 compares to the Jetta, not to the Passat.

I for one in principle cross-shop the GTI, R32, A3, and A4 wagon. Haven't bought anything because of the lack of 5-door 2.0TSFI AWD combo (especially manual) except for the A4 wagon, which is currently more money (~$40K) than I want to spend for a car... especially when you can get a Passat 3.6 AWD for about or even under $30K after discounts.



VW EV, plug-in Hybrid, and/or 1.4-2.0 VVT&VVL T/dual-charged FSI engines for the US would be useful...
PhReE
Member



Offline

Member Since
9-15-2004
6862 posts

Taylorsville UT
2004 GTI VR6T Silverstone, 2001 Golf 1.8T 4DR, 1990 Corrado G60 (SOLD)

 Re: Driven: 2007 Audi S3 (George@Fourtitude) »« »

Oh there is a business case for it, I want one! I would prefer a 3 door but hey 5 door wouldnt be too bad.



-James
04 GTI Silverstone 24vT (GT35R, Precision FMIC, Area 51 SRI, 630cc, Unitronic, Bosch 044, 9:1, Tial 44mmWG, Tial 50mmBOV, DualStg MBC, Full 3" TB)
Water Cooled Q9550@3.85Ghz, 8GB DDR2, 128GB G.Skill Falcon SSD and 2.25TB Network Storage
Elite 24v #2 :: Elite 24VRT #11
>> http://zingledot.myminicity.com/sec | https://sourceforge.net/projects/imagizer2/ <<
» Return to A3 & S3 (8P)
Forum Jump
 

 

For advertising information Click Here


ZeroForum 2.1.2. ©2008 RelyNet, Inc.

For advertising information Click Here